Closing and re-opening the game didn't resolve the issue, dropping and picking up items used in crafting recipes also did nothing to resolve it.
Harvesting something that gives an item used in a recipe did resolve it however.
Edit: Not sure if it's related, but I'm unable to craft anything static (Like planting things or building a wall)
Edit2: closing and re-opening the game brought back the original bug, gathering most things doesn't seem to fix it this time. Will test further.
Edit3: It appears that unlocking a recipe that you didn't have before logging off the last time is the only way to fix it currently